An RFC to refuse a Join when the new material doesn't touch the body, citing five earlier reports of bodies ending up in pieces without anyone meaning it, including one where a Combine Intersect silently removed a whole body made of seven separate spheres.
Silent failure reported against solidcraft (tangency-labs)
What engineers report
A silent failure reported against solidcraft (tangency-labs): reports success, or uses stale data, while the result is wrong or missing.
Recorded mode: agent / silent failure
Analyst note
From the Grok pain-radar digest, Oct 25-26 2026 (Oct 25 daytime to Oct 26 morning slots). Verified live 2026-10-26: issue/PR read on GitHub; title and state confirmed.
What it costs a team
Modeled annual cost
$30,000
For a team of 5
Prototype delay
3 days
Modeled schedule slip per occurrence
Time lost
240 min
Per engineer per month, about 1 incidents
How the cost is modeled
240 min/month × 5 engineers × 12 months = 240 hours × $125/hour = $30,000
A modeled estimate with medium confidence. Swap in your own team size and loaded rate to size it for your team.
Engineering tools that address it
Evidence
More recurring errors in solidcraft (tangency-labs)
- A FreeCAD PartDesign Body that FreeCAD calls one valid solid opens in SolidCraft as 5 open bodies with no volume, because the importer reads every intermediate shape in the archive, sketches included.Mechanical · impact 74
- A hole pattern feature drew 18 vent holes (6x3 grid of 6 mm) and cut almost none of them: 18 holes should have removed 1,221 mm3, measured removal was 124 mm3. The timeline shows no error or warning, and the snapshot still draws all 18 hole circles, which makes it easy to trust by eye and miss in checking.Mechanical · impact 74
- A large sketch imported from Fusion 360 into SolidCraft stalls on extrude, showing computing indefinitely and never finishing the operation.Mechanical · impact 74
- A user's design imports a multi-solid STEP of a KiCad board (181-182 solids) with a skip list. After upgrading from 0.30.1 to 0.40.1, the bare PCB body is gone, components float in space, kept parts are missing, and parts that were skipped show up again: 204 to 220 bodies against 193 before. No error on the import feature, so the damage is silent. The cause is that the skip list stores 82 positional indices, and the new importer returns the same solids in a different order. Any ECAD-to-MCAD handoff that keys on order instead of identity breaks like this.Mechanical · impact 74
- Cylinder, modelled M10 thread, then Shell on an end face: Shell fails because the faceted thread leaves the body as triangles, not a valid solid, so fillets and booleans downstream fail too. The reporter argues the 'temporary' faceted cut will harden into a ceiling.Mechanical · impact 74
- Extruding a connector boss up to the enclosure face with Join merged the enclosure into the connector body and took the connector name, so every later feature referencing the enclosure faces failed and the PCB sketched on it disappeared.Mechanical · impact 74
Sourced from public community reports. Costs and delays are modeled estimates, not measurements. Know a better source or a fix? Tell us at hello@productflo.io.