pkidl (feastorg) errors

4 failures reported against pkidl (feastorg), sorted by how they fail and ranked by impact.

#141 by errors trackedElectronics & PCB

Recurring pkidl (feastorg) errors, by impact

  1. 1A bench power supply board meets every bar it was given: KiCad's only errors are the reference design's, nothing unconnected, pad spacing above 1.36 mm. Two separate part-by-part reviews still say don't send it to fab. Output-net copper runs 0.31 mm from a meter's mounting hole edge, where an M3 head or standoff will sit on it. Nothing in the board rules knows where the mechanical hardware goes.Electronics & PCB · Wrong verdict · 1 report74
  2. 2On a fan controller board, Freerouting 2.5.0 reported 0 unrouted, and KiCad found a capacitor's ground unconnected. The router counted every pad on a copper pour as joined, but tracks crossing the pour cut off an island with pads on it. The fix fills the pours itself after routing and checks, net by net, whether pads, tracks, vias and pour pieces are actually joined. The router's own done was not trustworthy, so they built a second check.Electronics & PCB · Wrong verdict · 1 report66
  3. 3pkidl routes a board a second time when pours leave pads cut off, and that second routing was never checked until now. KiCad 10.0.6 names the starved GND thermals on the next-bus clock board (D1, C5, C6, SR1 pads against the B.Cu zone), but pkidl's own model of the fill does not report a starved relief. Built without KiCad, the same board comes back with nothing left, and the PR says plainly the error is still on the board.Electronics & PCB · Wrong verdict · 1 report66
  4. 4The fifth case where pkidl's own model of what a copper pour joins says joined and KiCad says unconnected. This one is a thermal-relief pad of the pour's own net sitting in the only gap through a wall of other copper. KiCad cuts the fill back by the thermal gap and the far side is cut off. The project's rule now is that the model only answers where KiCad is not installed; where it is, KiCad decides.Electronics & PCB · Wrong verdict · 1 report66

How it fails

  1. Wrong verdict4

Sourced from public community reports. Costs and delays on individual entries are modeled estimates, not measurements.